Plenty Market and Cafe

1967 Yonge St, Toronto, ON M4S 1Z7, Canada
$$$ cafe
(38 Reviews)
Price Range $1–20

Welcome to Plenty Market and Cafe, a delightful gem nestled on 1967 Yonge St in Toronto, ON. This charming cafe offers a warm and inviting atmosphere for those looking to indulge in carefully crafted coffee and mouth-watering baked goods.

Step inside and immerse yourself in a space that boasts a friendly vibe, where every corner radiates a sense of community. The shining star of Plenty Market and Cafe is its extensive coffee menu, with customer favorites including rich Americanos that are praised for their smoothness and depth. Patrons rave about the consistently exceptional quality of the coffee, ensuring that each visit feels like a treat. Zita Lau expressed her joy over the delightful mocha and latte, highlighting the richness in flavor that keeps customers coming back.

The baked goods at Plenty are not to be overlooked. From hearty, satisfying pastries to inspired salads and hearty soups, every dish reflects a commitment to quality and freshness. One of the standout offerings is the Plum Earl Grey confiture—a delightful spread that promises to tantalize your taste buds. Customer Blanca Bugler couldn't resist trying this alongside a nice oat cap, showcasing the inventive spirit of the cafe's menu.

For those who appreciate a well-crafted froth, the misto service here is unparalleled, as mentioned by loyal customer Martha McLean, while the excellent team, including Sophia, ensures that your experience is memorable and personalized. With such attentive and compassionate staff, it’s easy to see why this cafe has garnered a positive reputation within the city.

Wesley T. echoes this sentiment, praising Plenty Market and Cafe for its perfect blend of espresso drinks and tasty takeaway options that make it an ideal pit stop during a leisurely walk along Yonge Street. Whether you're on a caffeine run, looking to grab a quick bite, or simply seeking a cozy spot to unwind, Plenty is equipped to serve you with a smile.

If you're in the neighborhood, make sure to take the time to visit Plenty Market and Cafe. With delicious coffee expertly prepared and a welcoming atmosphere, each visit feels like a warm embrace. Come for the cozy vibes, stay for the exceptional food and drink—Plenty is indeed a place where you'll always find something to delight your palate and brighten your day.

Service options
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in
Highlights
Great coffee
Great tea selection
Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Solo dining
Offerings
Coffee
Quick bite
Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dessert
Amenities
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Trendy
Payments
Credit cards
38 Reviews
Zita Lau

19 Sep 2025

Not usually one to leave a review but we absolutely enjoyed the muffin, mocha and latte. Will definitely go again when we are in the area!

Martha McLean

18 Sep 2025

The Americanos are delicious! Good quality baked goods and I can expect a consistent smooth, rich coffee each visit. Shanaya and Elana make perfect froth on a misto :)

Josanne B

21 Aug 2025

An excellent cafe with hearty soups, rich pastries, and inspired salads. Everything is clean and organized. The Plenty Market team is so great; Sophia helped me during my visit. She was extremely attentive, compassionate, and efficient. This is the perfect pit stop during a walk on Yonge. Cafe Plenty has a positive reputation in the city, and it is totally deserved. I cannot recommend Plenty Market and Cafe enough!

Arsalan E

17 Aug 2025

Great little cafe with good coffee and delicious pastries. The staff are also very welcoming and friendly. Highly recommend trying this place if you are in the neighbourhood.

Blanca Bugler

02 Aug 2025

Nice oat cap Had to try the Plum Earl Grey confiture and noisette spread… looks delish.

Wesley T.

29 May 2025

Charming little midtown cafe offering excellent espresso drinks and pastries, plus delicious take-away meal options and treats!

Join the Plenty Market and Cafe Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.